Overview
Winter’s Tale is a romantic fantasy movie from 2014, released under the direction and script of Akiva Goldsman, which marked his directorial debut. The film revolves these a novel “Winter’s Tale” written by Mark Helprin in 1983, and is a compelling combination of historical romance, spiritual allegory, and supernatural fantasy. It includes an impressive ensemble cast of Colin Farrell, Jessica Brown Findlay, Russell Crowe, Will Smith, and many others, making the movie further focus on themes of destiny, miracles, and love. angee’s collage
Though, the movie was aimed to have a high profile cast, the story lacked the creativity which resulted in the movie performing poorly in both critical reception and business. With an estimate budget of 75 million dollars, the film had a gross of just 30 million dollars, making around only 30% of the budget.
Plot Summary
The story starts in the late 19th century, with a couple of immigrants in a dire situation of being denied entry into New York. The couple sacrifices their lives by putting their baby in a floating boat which is then spotted. The baby in this situation is Peter Lake, and he is a skilled thief in the early 20th century New York.
On the run from his former mentor, the crime lord Pearly Soames, who is prone to demonic outbursts, Peter breaks in to a mansion to escape the city and comes face to face with Beverly Penn, a strikingly beautiful, consumption-stricken young woman. Rather than stealing from her, Peter falls head over heels. Their connection is instantaneous, profound, and almost magical.
Beverly’s life hangs by a thread, but Peter becomes strangely determined to rescue her from death’s grip. In his discovery, Beverly’s life is just one example of the countless miracles each individual is born to perform. To Peter, his miracle is rewriting Beverly’s fate. Nonetheless, Pearly, who serves a dark celestial entity, attempts to intervene to Mantain the so-called balance of good vs evil.
In a jolt, the story shifts to present day New York City. Peter, who unfathomably survived over a century without aging and, most interestingly, without memories, ventures to a terminally ill young girl. With the assistance of journalist Virginia, he slowly starts recalling pieces of his life and learns the true miracle he was always meant to perform.
Performances and Characters
Colin Farrell portrays Peter Lake, playing the character with a soft and charming tone. Romantic and emotional, especially considering the plot lacks at times, he carries the romantic core of the film. His depiction of a man out of time merges fragility with subtle strength.
Jessica Brown Findlay plays Beverly Penn, imbuing the character with grace and thinness. Findlay’s depiction of a woman who knows she is running out of time evokes the film’s emotional center, providing a ghostly and captivating presence. Farrell and Findlay’s chemistry makes the otherwise fantastical love story believable.
Russell Crowe plays Pearly Soames, a supernatural, menacing supporting character who is a gangster. Crowe’s performance, while eccentric, was fascinating because he serves as a physical and metaphysical menace to Peter’s journey.
As a brief but surprising figure, Will Smith plays a judge with subtle hints of Lucifer. His depiction of the character is limited but laden with meaning, depicting the spiritual conflict that underlies the film’s world.
Connelly and Hurt, in their supporting roles, also lend the plot emotional weight and make the story feel more real, even though their time is limited.
Direction and Cinematography
In Akiva Goldsman’s direction, he steers for splendor as he captures the film’s visuals on a grand scale straddling between myth and melodrama. While well known for screenplays, Goldsman as a director on this film of such personal magnitude, as he previously quite as a director on movies such as I, Robot and A Beautiful Mind.
Without a doubt, the film’s visuals are jaw-dropping. Caleb Deschanel, the cinematographer, captures the frosty splendor of turn of the century New York, rich with freezing cold landscapes glowing candlelit interiors, and magical cityscapes of the glowing cosmos. Ethereal lighting and atmospheric effects, like the haze surrounding the objects, combine and create a blend of fantasy and reality, a trademark of magical realism.
Themes and Symbolism
In this film, the light and darkness are battling over abstract concepts of miracles, eternal love, and fate. The film gives the message that every person has a certain purpose, a masterpiece that needs to be performed, and that love can transcend the bounds of time and death.
The white horse that comes to save Peter halfway during the film signifies divine guidance. While the horse gives a person the ride, its true purpose is to act as a heavenly creature that’s taking Peter to where he is supposed to be. The film’s spiritual side is further enhanced by the notion of time bending and folding into itself where the past and present co-exist.
Character Analysis
Pearly, in turn, symbolizes the malignant imagination of evil powers that are striving, and will always strive, to stamp out miracles and hope. In a way, Pearly’s connection to a dark and deeper power creates an additional layer of cosmic conflict to what could be just a straightforward love story.
Critical and Commercial Reception
Critics did not respond well to the film as a whole, explaining that it was a jumble of way too many subplots without a focus on a core storyline. The lofty aspirations of the film are met, rather unsuccessfully, and dividends are paid out because of the lack of focus in the film’s plot and dialogue. Sentimentality is overflowed in the dialogue. The blending of genres such as romance, fantasy, and religious musings is something that many filmgoers could identify with. A certain faction of the audience appreciated the movie’s distinct execution that crashed and burned.
The box office was hit the hardest. The film significantly underperformed. The fantasy and religious components of the film, although being marketed as a romance flick due to the Valentine’s season, did not help the film’s reception and ultimately pushed away the audience that was being targeted.
Legacy and Reflection
Winter’s Tell is a deeply perceived film and a curiosity in the styled romantic fantasy, due to the backlash it had received because of the mix of love and magic paired with some spiritual motifs. Many consider this film to be an example of a failure, one that tried to ‘grab the stars’ and, as many believe, fell flat on its face because of a lack of execution.
It does underscore the risks filmmakers assume when seeking to adapt a deep novel with abstract themes, though. To some degree, Goldsman’s efforts to give a contemporary form to a myth were quite commendable, and while the outcome was rather incomplete, it still ties into his apparent ardor for the source material.
Conclusion
A film with exquisite visual and performing artistry, Winter’s Tale is a story of love, loss, and miracles that at the same time overreaches its grasp. It certainly has some moments of real emotion and breathtaking visuals, but the film’s convoluted plot, combined with its inconsistent tone, makes it less appealing.
That said, the film provides a one of a kind experience, mystical romance, and high-concept fantasy, and, although flawed, it is still a distinct gem. It is a cinematic fairy tale that poses grand cinematic questions, although it does not always discover the right answers.
Watch Free Movies on Sflix